One Price for the Whole Package: What Is an Undelivered Part of the Contract Worth?
Contracts often combine several different services, rights or deliverables into a single package with one overall price. This can be convenient in a commercial proposal: the client buys the end result, while the service provider does not have to disclose the pricing of every component. However, the contract’s scope and price should be described clearly enough to establish not only what the client is paying for, but also what happens if only part of the agreed package is delivered.
Suppose a contract schedule states that the client is acquiring a perpetual licence to a brand and technology. A single combined fee for both parts of the licence is payable upon signing the contract.
The contract defines the “Brand” as the name and logo. “Technology” is defined much more broadly to include software, applications, platforms, patents, know-how, confidential information and other technological solutions required to operate the business.
At first glance, the scope of the contract appears to be set out. Yet the wording does not make clear which specific technologies are covered by the fee, which versions must be delivered, or whether updates, implementation and technical support are included. The same issue arises with the brand: a brand book might logically be included, but the contract does not say whether it is.
The problem becomes particularly significant if the contract is only partly performed. For example, the client may receive the right to use the brand, but not some of the technology. Or the technology may be delivered, but cannot be used without additional licences, access rights or technical documentation.
In that situation, the parties need to determine what part of the price the client should pay or is entitled to recover. If the entire contract price is assigned to one combined licence, the contract provides no answer. The service provider may argue that the brand made up most of the package’s value. The client may take the opposite view: without the technology, the licence has none of its intended commercial value, since the client was never particularly interested in the brand itself.
The dispute then concerns more than whether the contract was breached. The parties must also establish the value of the undelivered component, the appropriate amount of any price reduction or refund, and whether the remaining part of the contract can still be used for its intended purpose. When the contract does not address these questions, the parties often develop their positions only after a dispute has arisen, drawing on internal calculations, market prices and expert assessments.
This risk is not limited to licensing or technology contracts.
The same issue can arise when a single price covers:
- equipment, its installation and staff training;
- a brand, a website and an advertising campaign;
- design, supervision of the works and handover of the completed project;
- business analysis, a strategy and its implementation.
While the entire package is delivered, breaking down the price may seem like unnecessary bookkeeping.
When one component is not delivered, it becomes clear that the breakdown was not just bookkeeping. It would have shown how much you paid for that component.
There is no need to disclose the commercial price of every screw in the contract. One possible solution is to list in a schedule the specific deliverables, their delivery dates, acceptance criteria and the percentage of the total price allocated to each component. This allocation can be used solely to calculate the amount payable, any price reduction or any refund if part of the contractual obligations is not fulfilled.
If the package components have no standalone value and the client is purchasing only a single, integrated end result, the contract should say so clearly. It should then specify whether failure to deliver an essential component counts as failure to deliver the entire package and what rights the client has in that event.
It is also worth linking payments to specific stages of performance. If the full amount is paid upon signing, the client is financing a result that has not yet been delivered and gives up some of its bargaining power. Payment by instalments—for example, part of the price on signing, part when specific rights are transferred and the remainder after acceptance of a working result—better aligns payment with actual performance.
Before setting one price for several services or rights, check three things: whether the scope of each package component is clearly described, whether the point at which it is delivered can be objectively determined, and whether the contract explains the financial consequences if that component is not delivered.
A single package price can be convenient in negotiations and on an invoice. If a dispute arises, the package will have to be unpacked anyway—it is better to do that in the contract than after a breach.