Early Contract Termination: How Long Can the Client Retain Payment?
Construction contracts often provide that the client withholds a portion of each payment—for example, 5%—until the contractor provides a warranty guarantee or surety insurance letter, or until the warranty period expires. Contracts usually link the start of the warranty period to the building being recognised as fit for use. In practice, however, contracts often fail to say what happens to retained amounts if the contract is terminated before the works are complete and the contractor will no longer finish the building.
The Supreme Court of Lithuania addressed this issue in its ruling of 7 October 2026 in civil case No. e3K-3-120-1075/2026.
A contractor building residential houses subcontracted the façade works. The subcontract provided that 95% of each invoice would be paid immediately, with the remaining 5% retained. The contractor was to pay the retained amount after approving the final works acceptance certificate and receiving a warranty guarantee or surety insurance letter. If no such letter was provided, payment was due only after the first three years of the building’s warranty period had expired. The warranty period was calculated from the date the building was recognised as fit for use.
The subcontractor fell behind schedule, so the contractor terminated the contract unilaterally. The contractor later agreed with the client to reduce the scope of work to the works already completed to the required standard, and the client hired other contractors to finish the construction. The building was never recognised as fit for use, the subcontractor did not provide a warranty guarantee or surety insurance letter, and it later went bankrupt.
In court, the subcontractor sought payment for the completed works, including the retained 5%. The lower courts ruled that the contractor’s right to retain those amounts had ended when the contract was terminated.
The Court reiterated that retention is a contractual method of securing the performance of an obligation. The parties decide whether to include it in their contract and the conditions under which it will apply. Its purpose is to help cover the client’s losses if the contractor fails, or is unable, to fulfil its warranty obligations. This contractual right should not be confused with the contractor’s statutory obligation under the Law on Construction to provide security for the performance of its obligations.
The contract in this case did not specify how the retention would operate if the contract was terminated early. The court must fill such a gap by taking into account the parties’ intentions, the purpose of the contract, and the principles of reasonableness and good faith.
The Supreme Court agreed with the lower courts that, after the contract is terminated, it would not be reasonable to tie the retention period to the start of the warranty period for the entire building—particularly because the contractor was no longer responsible for completing the project. In other words, the client cannot be expected to wait until the building is eventually recognised as fit for use.
At the same time, the Supreme Court disagreed that the right to retain payment simply ends. Even after a construction contract is terminated, the contractor remains liable for defects in work already handed over, and that work is also subject to warranty periods. The client’s interest in retaining part of the payment therefore remains, even if the completed work was of the required quality. In that situation, the retention period runs from the start of the warranty period for the work that was handed over—in other words, from the handover date.
In practice, construction contracts often set different rates of default interest for each party. A party drafting the contract may impose substantial interest if the other party is late, calculated on the total contract price, while setting a much lower rate for its own late payments, calculated only on the overdue amount. This may seem advantageous to the party drafting the contract, but such a term may not withstand judicial scrutiny if a dispute arises.
That is what happened in this case. The subcontractor was required to pay up to 0.2% of the total contract price for each day of delay, while the contractor’s late-payment interest was only 0.02% of the unpaid amount. The courts considered the penalties disproportionate and punitive in nature, and halved the default interest calculated by the contractor. The Supreme Court agreed because the contractor had not substantiated the amount claimed by reference to the losses it could reasonably have expected to incur.
When drafting a contract, default interest should therefore be set at rates that are proportionate for both parties and reflect the losses that a delay could realistically cause. Such a term is fairer and more likely to hold up in a dispute.
- What happens to retained amounts if the contract is terminated early: when the retention period starts and how long it lasts.
- How the handover of completed work will be documented when the contract ends, since the handover starts both the warranty period and the retention period.
- Whether the contractor can recover retained amounts by providing a warranty guarantee or surety insurance letter after termination.
- Whether the default interest rates are balanced between the parties. Clearly one-sided penalties are likely to be reduced if a dispute arises.