December 30 2021

Ruling of the Supreme Court of Lithuania on the legality of corporate governing body decisions

Supreme Court of Lithuania Ruling on the Legality of Corporate Governing Body Decisions

The Supreme Court of Lithuania (LAT) issued ruling No. e3K-3-294-823/2021, addressing the legality of corporate governing body decisions.

In this case, the plaintiff, a company shareholder holding 60% of shares (while the third party owned 40%), sought to invalidate a decision made at an extraordinary general meeting to amend the company’s bylaws. The amendment required a qualified two-thirds majority vote for the appointment and removal of the company’s CEO and board members.

Key Findings of the LAT Ruling:

1️⃣ Risk of Deadlock: Given the long-standing shareholder conflict, the bylaw amendment, which required near unanimous agreement, could lead to decision-making deadlock, effectively paralyzing the company’s governance and harming business operations.

2️⃣ Imbalance in Shareholder Rights: The bylaw changes favored the third party, expanding its control over the company’s management, while significantly limiting the plaintiff’s decision-making power.

3️⃣ Bad Faith Decision-Making: The third party’s argument that the changes would stabilize the company’s governance was ultimately a pretext to increase its control. The decision was made against the plaintiff’s will, using voting rights from shares originally transferred by the plaintiff, which the court deemed not in good faith (bona fide).

This ruling underscores the importance of fair decision-making in corporate governance and the risks of bylaws that disproportionately benefit one shareholder while restricting another.

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Business trends and legal insights — all in one place.

Please wait...

Dėkojame! Sekmingai prisiregistravote

Let's talk

    Cookies

    This website uses essential and statistical cookies to ensure the attractive display of the Prevence website, maintain its functionality, and provide a smooth browsing experience.

    Essential cookies are a condition for using our website. If you choose to reject these types of cookies, we cannot guarantee the proper functioning of the website during your visit. You can manage the use of functional and third-party cookies by adjusting your browser settings.

    The legal basis for processing data collected through cookies is your consent. We do not link a visitor’s IP address or email address to data that would enable their identification. This means that each visitor’s session will be recorded, but visitors to the Prevence website will remain anonymous.

    When using a browser to access our content, you can configure your browser to accept all cookies, reject all cookies, or notify you when a cookie is sent. Each browser is different, so if you are unsure how to adjust your cookie settings, check the help menu of your browser. Your device’s operating system may also offer additional cookie controls. If you do not wish information to be collected through cookies, use the simple procedure available in most browsers that allows you to decline the use of cookies. To learn more about managing cookies, visit: http://www.allaboutcookies.org/manage-cookies/.